Understanding the Roots and Benefits of Diversification in Investing
Written on
Chapter 1: The Concept of Diversification
In the realm of investing, the principle of diversification is rarely questioned. It is widely accepted that having a diversified portfolio is advantageous, and that more diversity often equates to less risk. Let's delve into the origins of these benefits.
To begin, let’s consider why diversification is generally favorable. Picture a scenario where you have the chance to flip a coin just once. If the result is heads, you win $2.00, but if it’s tails, you lose $1. The expected payoff can be calculated as follows:
0.5 * 2.0 + 0.5 * -1.0 = 0.5 dollars
This positive expected return suggests that you should go ahead and flip. However, there remains a risk, as there's a 50% chance that you could lose your wager. If many individuals were to bet all their savings on this coin flip, around half would end up with a 200% gain, while the other half would face financial ruin. There’s no middle ground—it's either a huge win or a devastating loss.
Thus, betting your entire life savings on a single coin flip would be imprudent. Nevertheless, due to the appealing expected payoff, it makes sense to stake at least a portion of your funds.
Now, consider a scenario where instead of flipping one coin, you could flip two coins at the same time, with each coin offering the same potential payoffs as before. If you distribute your wager evenly across both coins, the potential outcomes would be as follows:
Tails, Tails -> -0.5 + -0.5 = -1 dollar
Tails, Heads -> -0.5 + 1.0 = +0.5 dollars
Heads, Tails -> 1.0 + -0.5 = +0.5 dollars
Heads, Heads -> 1.0 + 1.0 = +2.0 dollars
Each of these outcomes carries an equal probability (25% chance each). The expected payoff remains:
0.25 * -1 + 0.25 * 0.5 + 0.25 * 0.5 + 0.25 * 2 = 0.5 dollars
Although the expected payoff hasn’t changed, the distribution of outcomes has. If a large group were to spread their bets evenly across the two coins, 25% would become wealthy (up 200%), while another 25% would go broke. Importantly, half would walk away with a reasonable 50% return, a significant improvement over the previous scenario where half would be left financially devastated. Now, 75% of participants would leave with a profit or at least break even, and only 25% would lose their stakes.
However, it is crucial to note that the likelihood of attaining a massive win (200% gain) has diminished from 50% to 25%. By sacrificing some potential upside, you gain a more favorable risk distribution—especially if you are not prone to gambling.
The favorable distribution arises from the independence of the two coin flips; the result of the first flip does not affect the second. Adding a third coin further changes the distribution (illustrated in the gray columns below), reducing the chances of extreme outcomes. Now, only 12.5% of bettors would face losses or windfalls.
As more coins are introduced, the distribution approaches a bell curve centered around the expected payout of 0.5. Moreover, the distribution narrows (i.e., the standard deviation decreases), leading to a reduced likelihood of extreme outcomes. For instance, with ten coins, the probability of losing everything (getting tails on all flips) drops to just 0.1%—a stark contrast to the 50% chance of losing when flipping one coin.
Key Insights from Diversification
This analysis highlights several important takeaways regarding the nature of diversification:
- Uncorrelated Bets: Diversification arises from identifying multiple independent bets. Each additional coin represents another uncorrelated wager, enhancing overall diversification.
- Positive Expected Payoffs: The expected returns of each bet matter significantly. If all outcomes are favorable, diversification increases the likelihood of positive results. Conversely, if outcomes are negative, excessive diversification can lead to guaranteed losses.
- Independence: True independence implies a correlation of zero. In reality, most investments are somewhat correlated (e.g., U.S. and European stocks), which means the benefits of diversification may not be as pronounced as in our coin example.
- Temporal Diversification: Diversification can occur both across different investments and over time. Continuously repeating bets over the years minimizes the risk of total loss. As long as you avoid complete wipeout, you enhance your opportunities for success.
Chapter 2: The Importance of Diversification Strategies
Understanding the importance of diversification is crucial for successful investing. The first video, "What is Diversification? [and Why Buffett is WRONG]," dives into the nuances of diversification and challenges common perceptions.
The second video, "Diversification Explained in 3 Minutes in Basic English," succinctly explains the concept of diversification in an easily digestible format, making it accessible for all investors.