Executives Are Misguided: Reasons for Office Returns Explored

Understanding Misguided Office Return Strategies

In a large corporation with over ten thousand employees worldwide, the quick closure of offices at the onset of the pandemic showcased a commitment to employee safety. However, the journey back to the office has been fraught with confusion and inconsistency, marked by various attempts to balance remote work and in-office presence.

The company has cycled through different arrangements, including alternating weeks of in-office and remote work, and varying mandated and optional office days. These changes often feel like an awkward attempt to force a solution that doesn't fit the modern work environment. The motivations behind these office return policies often reflect flawed reasoning or a fundamental misunderstanding of workforce dynamics.

The Misconception of Face-to-Face Interaction

One common belief among executives is that employees long for in-person interactions. This notion often stems from feedback gathered by Human Resources, which can overlook the preferences of introverted employees. My CEO has stated, “this decision [to return to the office] arises from feedback indicating that you miss face-to-face interactions.”

In a recent company-wide meeting, I highlighted that the desire for in-person contact predominantly comes from extroverted individuals, who are more likely to voice their opinions. With approximately one-third of the workforce identifying as introverted, this perspective can marginalize a significant segment of employees.

Photo by Rachel McDermott on Unsplash

The Fallacy of Improved Communication

Another argument is that in-person interactions enhance communication efficiency. While it’s true that face-to-face meetings can facilitate discussions, my experience suggests otherwise. I find my productivity increases when I can focus on spoken words without the distractions of visual cues—like eye rolls or sighs—that can misinterpret the conversation's tone.

Initially, during the pandemic, it was refreshing to see everyone on video calls ignoring these non-verbal signals, allowing us to proceed with our work without unnecessary distractions. While in-person meetings may lead to more dialogue, it doesn’t always equate to better communication.

Your Colleagues Are More Accessible

The idea that being in the office makes coworkers more reachable primarily translates to executives wanting increased access to their teams. I recognize the value of being present to engage with my team, but I also understand that these interactions often disrupt their workflow rather than promote productivity.

In a typical office environment, I frequently experience interruptions that can derail focus. I’ve started asking colleagues to consider whether their questions could be addressed via email or messaging platforms instead. This approach respects both their time and mine, allowing for asynchronous communication that can be more efficient.

The Trust Deficit

Although few executives openly express it, there seems to be an underlying assumption that remote workers may not be genuinely engaged in their tasks. The reality is that a lack of productivity is not confined to any particular working environment; motivated employees will find ways to excel regardless of where they are based.

Photo by Fábio Silva on Unsplash

Observing the Office Dynamics

For those managing teams, it’s essential to take a step back and assess the current office landscape. Are conference rooms filled with engaged participants, or are they now often vacant? Before the pandemic, scheduling a meeting room was a challenge. Now, they frequently remain unused, with many of the meetings I attend occurring only when scheduled by upper management.

Often, these meetings are delayed as leaders juggle their numerous commitments, indicating a disconnect between the expectation of office presence and actual engagement.

Chapter 2: Perspectives from Employees

Understanding the Do's and Don'ts of Office Returns

The first video titled, "The Do's And Don'ts Of Returning To The Office | WorkLife with Adam Grant" offers insights into how to navigate the complexities of returning to the workplace, focusing on employee well-being and productivity.

Addressing the Mismatch in Office Expectations

The second video, "The Great Mismatch: Why Return to Office Is Not As Easy As We Thought," discusses the challenges and misalignments in expectations surrounding the return to office work, emphasizing the need for understanding employee sentiments.