# The Fascinating Science of Tea Leaves in a Cup
Written on
Understanding Everyday Phenomena
In our everyday lives, we encounter numerous ordinary occurrences that often go unnoticed. Some of these are engineered by humans, while others are natural. These phenomena can seem mundane, but when we pause to consider their underlying reasons, we uncover the remarkable explanations that science provides. Frequently, the principles governing these simple observations also explain significant human-made and natural events. In this article, we will delve into one such everyday occurrence and reveal its broader implications.
The Teacup Observation
Many of us have noticed that after stirring a cup of tea, the leaves tend to congregate in the center. This seems counterintuitive, especially when compared to the experience of a merry-go-round, where we feel pushed outward from the center. One would expect the tea leaves to move toward the cup’s edge after stirring. So, why do they collect in the center instead? Let’s explore this question further.
Figure 1 illustrates two cups filled with liquid. In one (cup A), the liquid's surface is level, while in the other (cup B), the surface is curved. Can you identify which cup is being stirred?
Indeed, it’s cup B. When stirred, the liquid dips at the center (as demonstrated in a video that visually represents this phenomenon). This effect is akin to how a container spins, creating a similar motion to that of the liquid in a stirred cup.
To understand why the tea leaves end up in the center, we must examine the cause of the dip in the liquid's surface.
The Dynamics of Liquid Motion
Figure 2 depicts a cross-section of the liquid just after stirring ceases. Consider a minuscule liquid element (shown in white) located at a distance r from the cup’s axis. Its depths from the liquid surface are h₁ and h₂, with h₁ being greater than h₂. But why must h₁ exceed h₂?
According to Newton's second law of motion, the net force acting on an object results in a proportional acceleration. For instance, if you push a stationary object, you exert a force that initiates its motion. The net force required to accelerate an object must be non-zero.
Acceleration can also arise from changing the direction of an object’s velocity, as seen in circular motion. Here, the velocity's direction alters (the magnitude may remain constant), creating centripetal acceleration directed towards the axis of rotation.
Therefore, for the liquid element in Figure 2, which moves in a circle, centripetal acceleration is present, and a net force must act on it. Where does this force originate? Let’s investigate further.
Understanding Pressure and Forces
We are enveloped by the atmosphere, which exerts pressure on us due to the weight of the air above. When scuba diving, the pressure also includes that from a column of water, mathematically expressed as ρgh (where ρ is the liquid’s density, g is gravitational acceleration, and h is depth). The pressure acting on the liquid element in Figure 2 combines atmospheric pressure (pₐ) with the pressure from the liquid column above it.
Since h₁ is greater than h₂, the pressure on one side of the liquid element (pₐ + ρgh₁) exceeds that on the other (pₐ + ρgh₂). This difference generates forces acting on the liquid element, leading to a net force that facilitates its circular motion.
To quantify this, we use the relation:
[ F = p cdot A ]
where S (S = x²) is the area on which the force acts. This implies that the net force pushes the liquid elements towards the center, confirming that for every rotating liquid element, the condition h₁ > h₂ must hold true, establishing the dip at the cup's center.
Mathematical Insights
Newton’s second law for the liquid element states:
[ ma = F ]
where m is the mass of the element, a is its centripetal acceleration, and F is the net force acting on it. The centripetal acceleration for circular motion is described as rω², where ω is the angular velocity.
If the angular velocity remains constant, the difference in height (h₁ - h₂) increases with distance from the axis, causing the surface to steepen and form a dip.
When we cease stirring, the liquid surface does not immediately flatten. It retains its curvature for a time, as depicted in Figure 5. Here, two liquid elements, one near the surface (p) and another near the bottom (q), are examined.
The viscosity of the liquid means that the element in contact with the cup remains stationary. As we move away from the surface, the liquid gains speed, resulting in differing angular velocities between p and q. While the net forces acting on both elements are equal, the slower-moving element q experiences less centripetal acceleration, causing it to be pushed more towards the center than element p.
This deceleration is nonuniform based on proximity to the cup's surface, leading to the formation of vortices, illustrated in Figure 6, which drives the tea leaves toward the center.
Connecting to Broader Natural Phenomena
I promised to link this simple teacup phenomenon to larger natural occurrences. Consider the erosion and sedimentation processes at a river bend. Over time, the outer bank erodes while sediment builds up on the inner bank. Why does this happen?
References
- Varlamov, A. A., Aslamazov, L. G., The Wonders of Physics, World Scientific.
- Physics Stack Exchange
- Tea Leaf Paradox